Kristy Black Creative case study

Kristy Black Creative case study

A Clear Strategy And On-Brand Copy 5xed This Entrepreneurs’s Email List In Under 2 Years, Increasing Her Authority And Warm Leads

Client: Kristy Black of Kristy Black Creative

Industry: Branding and design offerings for mission-driven, disruptive and audacious businesses; goal coaching for entrepreneurs

Service: Quarterly content strategy calls and email copywriting for 2 projects spanning just under 2 years – welcome sequence, 2x monthly newsletter

Results: A 5x increase in email subscribers, above average open and click-through-rates, a better understanding of her own brand voice, and industry authority that brings in warmer leads

Kristy Black, Brand Strategist, Designer, and Coach at Kristy Black Creative

Kristy Black offers branding, strategy, design, and coaching services to entrepreneurs who want to change the world while bringing more joy and clarity into their lives and businesses.

Kristy has been in business for over 12 years, so she understands how entrepreneurship can lead to burnout over time. Her focus – alongside coaching founders on how to reach their goals – is breathing life back into brands and the humans behind them.

First email of 2021 (left) & last of 2023 (right).

Our short-term goal

Increase email subscribers by strategizing and writing copy for her newsletter that positions Kristy as the authority on branding, goal coaching, and joyful entrepreneurship.

Now, Kristy has a clear content strategy that keeps her newsletter on-brand to attract subscribers, generate warm leads, and foster her loyal community.

5x email subscribers in under 2 years.

Above average open and click-through rates.

A better understanding of her brand voice.

Industry authority that brings in warmer leads.

“Erin Cafferty is an absolute delight to work with, and I can't recommend her enough. Through strategic planning sessions and her uncanny ability to adapt her writing to sound EXACTLY like me, Erin has helped me grow my email list to 5x its original size!

If you are looking for a collaborative copywriter who is a delight to work with and gets you incredible results, you need to work with Erin!”

As a solo entrepreneur, Kristy was ridden with guilt for not having an email list and felt overwhelmed by figuring out what to do or how to get people on it.

After 3 years of inaction, she ended up talking with a fellow business owner who referred her to me. That's when she reached out for help!

Working with Erin has been a game-changer in my business! Investing in a copywriter was one of those things that took a while for me to invest in because I was so used to doing it all on my own, but I’m SO glad I took the leap.
— Kristy Black

So she hired me to write on-brand newsletters that used storytelling to connect with her audience, increase subscribers, and bring in more warm leads.

Curious how we approached an ongoing project like this?

Here’s the process we went through – from creating the strategy that drove the copy I wrote for her newsletters to writing, editing, and getting feedback on the drafts – over the course of almost 2 years.

The process

  • My projects typically start with a 15-minute clarity call to discuss needs, goals, and budget. Since Kristy was referred by a client of mine, she requested to skip this step.

    Instead, I sent her a proposal detailing how I would help her start and nurture a monthly newsletter.

  • After she accepted my proposal, we had a 90-minute call where I dove deep into her business, background, and bigger vision for the future. Kristy brought relevant brand documents, audience information, competitor links, newsletter and social media analytics, and other resources that helped guide the questions.

    We reworked her strategy every quarter from July 2021-March 2023. She also received a copy of the strategy document after every call.

    During the calls, I asked questions to help define her short and long-term goals, messaging and copy needs, and target audience before I ever sat down to write the copy.

    For each email, we:

    • Got clear on the goal

    • Developed a relevant call to action

    • Connected the content’s focus with a monthly theme

    • Highlighted her related services to promote in the emails

  • The strategy calls gave me a lot to work with, but I always do additional research on my own.

    I used social listening to find pain points directly from her dream clients, created a word bank to keep the email copy on-brand, and reviewed Kristy’s past content to get a better understanding of her tone of voice, her brand archetype in action, and what her audience connected with the most.

    There are a lot of brand strategists out there, but Kristy has a unique approach to it that she wants to share with a larger audience. Joy is at the center of her mission, something that became obvious through the extra research I conducted.

    Uncovering this pattern and weaving it into the newsletter strategy led Kristy to officially name her newsletter The Joyful Entrepreneur!

  • Once Kristy was excited about the strategic direction of her newsletters and I did my own research, I started outlining the 2 newsletters for the month.

    Each outline included the monthly goal, theme, send schedule, two subject lines/preview texts so we could run A/B tests, and the newsletter content.

  • Once the outline was done, I walked away from the copy for a day or two.

    When I came back to it, I edited the copy to reflect my research, Kristy’s word bank, and our strategy call. This step was about aligning the content with her goal and making sure it read like Kristy wrote it.

  • For each of Kristy’s newsletters, I offered 1 round of edits. I gave her about 4-5 days to provide comments on the email drafts via Google Docs.

    She’s a booked-out business owner wearing many hats, so the goal was to make providing feedback quick and easy.

  • After Kristy’s feedback, I either implemented her suggestions or commented back my professional opinion on why we shouldn’t go in that direction.

    1-2 days after she left comments, I sent her the final copy of her newsletters. She then passed it along to her VA to format and schedule on FloDesk.

  • After the final copy was sent, our work was done until the following month!

    Typically, I sent a draft of the monthly newsletters by the 15th, she had edits in by the 20th, and I delivered the final a few days later. This was to ensure that the content was accessible to her well ahead of when it would be published the following month.

“I had no preconceived notions of what the process would look like before we talked, but it was perfect. Meeting quarterly, talking about goals/what was coming up, creating content calendars... It was a nice checkpoint, gave me clarity and benchmarks, and forced me to be a better planner as a business owner. It felt safe here.”

The results speak for themselves

A 250% increase in email subscribers in under 2 years, above average open and click-through rates driven by a loyal community, and an on-brand newsletter that brings in warm leads.

Kristy didn’t have a consistent newsletter before we worked together. What she did have was 10 years of experience as a brand strategist and designer.

We skyrocketed her email subscribers by developing a messaging strategy and writing email copy that positioned Kristy as the authority on branding, goal coaching, and joyful entrepreneurship.

Immediately, she experienced subscriber growth and had a clear strategy to work with that increased her visibility, generating more warm leads and fostering a community of loyal readers who trusted her expertise.

Seeing my own voice come through the emails helped me understand my brand voice.
— Kristy Black
  • Newsletter with a 59% open rate and 4.5% CTR

“I've been consistently blown away by Erin's ability to take my oftentimes disjointed ideas and transform them into impactful and on-brand newsletters (a MUST for me, considering I'm a brand strategist & designer)!

Additionally, I'm delighted to report that Erin also continues to give me the tools needed to think about ALL content creation in a new and more strategic light!

If you've been considering working with a copywriter to free up some space on your calendar, I cannot recommend Erin enough! She's truly wonderful to collaborate with and my business has thrived in so many ways as a result of her incredible talents!”

Want results like Kristy?

Strategic newsletter copy has the power to bring you more warm leads, increase subscribers and their loyalty, and give you the confidence to step into your role as the expert you are.